Review: American Teen

Exploding onto the scene at the 2008 Sundance Film Festival, American Teen gained instant pedigree and some serious buzz by taking the top honors for directing in a documentary. It was promptly snatched up by Paramount Vantage, and has seen a fairly robust limited release over the course of the summer.

The Skinny: With American Teen, director Nanette Burstein has delivered an unapologetic look into the lives of high school seniors growing up in middle-America which ranges from brutally honest and painfully funny at its best, to a cliche, glorified video yearbook at its worst. A 95 minute film cut from over 1000 hours of footage and filmed over the course of 10 months, American Teen focuses on four archetypal teens attending the same high school in Warsaw, Indiana. Hannah is the misunderstood free spirit, Colin the basketball star struggling to make it big, Jake the painfully awkward geek videogamer, and Megan the authoritative drama queen. In a very unique documentary style, the cast of characters' lives intermingle with each other and countless others as they fight through the backbreaking pressures and emotionally intense, if not melodramatic, challenges of their day-to-day lives in a very dramatic structure. Indeed, the conveniences and superb timing of the documentary and its film-makers can often seem to reach the point of feeling a bit scripted, but as a product of a generation of kids raised on reality television and placed within the midwestern/suburban culture that's all too familar, it might just be that the dreams, fears, and realities of the angst-filled lives portrayed here hit just a little too close to home.

+/- Full Review

Director Nanette Berstein (On the Ropes, The Kids Stay in the Picture) has said that she consciously widdled the film down to its four primary subjects not only for the broad-appeal archetypes that they represent, but because she felt that each individual had a well-defined purpose and an often painful inner-motivation that also rendered them timelessly relatable. Hannah is fighting a history of depression in her family while trying to escape from a town that desperately wants to hold onto her. Colin has had the unbearable pressure placed upon him of either playing well enough to earn a basketball scholarship or joining the military. Jake is fighting to find a girlfriend who understands him while also trying to vanquish the label of "loser" placed upon him from early on. And finally, Megan is a domineering bitch as a means of compensating for the suppressed guilt of her sister's suicide and her family's sky-high academic expectations of her. Despite the fact that each of these stories makes for compelling drama, one of the reasons that they fit into such concise descriptions is that they can feel a little bit forced. More often than not, each scenario is played out in an excessively literal fashion, leaving little room for nuance. This is especially the case with Jake, as no human being on Earth could be half as awkward as he is portrayed in this film. Also, the framing often leaves certain realities either distorted or completely omitted. Has Colin's father really never heard of student loans? Jake just flies out to San Diego to meet his older brother for a night of Tijiuna debauchery on a mere whim?

In general, although well done, the cinematography tends to add to this staged feel. Burstein didn't shoot this in a detached, documentarian style. She thought about staging and made the camera work dynamic, but unfortunatly it tends to detract from the sense of reality. Also, despite the fact the Burstein has denied all acusations of scripting, some of the conveniences are hard to let go. The cameras were set up and ready to go at the perfect opportunity to catch Hannah's moment of extreme anguish from being dumped by her boyfriend, manage to be present for both sides of a phone conversation between Jake's hopelessly miserable girlfriend and her outgoing "cool-guy" new crush, and present for an excessive number of people as they all receive emails and texts containing a naked picture of one of their female peers. The film also uses a series of animation sequences to represents individuals' dreams when they are expressing fantasies, aspirations, and even nightmares to themselves. Overall, these animations are a mixed bag, and distributed a bit unevenly throughout the film. Each person has a unique animation style to fit their own personality. Colin's description of his eventual rise from highschool star to NBA baller was flashy and entertaining, while Hannah's fall into self-loathing nightmare was sutiably disturbing, but a bit over-cooked. Jake likes to place himself in the shoes of hero Link from his Legend of Zelda videogame, but what begins as fresh and surprising ends up as annoying and overused.

Despite the blemishes and over-simplifications, there are also moments of clarity and undeniable relatability that are impossible to fake, and dripping with the careful nuance found lacking elsewhere. Late in the film Hannah finds herself in a unexpected relationship with "popular dude" Mitch. Despite the fact that the two have undeniable chemistry, and that Mitch especially clearly finds the relationship liberating, the fling is prematurely snuffed out by incompatible social circles and enforced behavioral norms. Also, there is a brief inteview with the afforementioned "nude-picture girl" which portrays a young women so utterly defeated by a vicious bout of 21st century character assasination that it's impossible not to feel mortified for her. And finally, in one of the most beutifully underplayed jokes I've ever seen, Jake spins his prom date to the audience as being a girl he had a fling with at a family wedding who happens to fly in to see him, while it's magnificiently apparent that his parents felt so bad that he couldn't find a date at his own school that they offered to fly in some twenty-something friend of the family who they probably asked to come as a favor. It's moments like that where the movie really breaks through the uncomfortable reality-TV barrier to feel like real life.

I went into American Teen and got exactly what I expected, but something just didn't feel right. There are identifiable elements to the documentary that are a bit distracting, but in the end it's undeniable that the drama and happenings found within are instantly identifiable as the quintessential high school experience, and the culture and lifestyle of Warsaw, Indiana is perfect microcasm of middle-American society in general. In the end, it's almost like a documentary version of the uncanny valley. For those scratching their heads, the uncanny valley is the notion that when robots or other representaions (i.e. CGI) reach a state of human likeness that is close but not perfect, that it creates a sense of revulsion among human observers. (See Robert Zemeckis's Beowulf.) American Teen is a perfect anthropological study of a young society inbreed with a healthy sense of melodrama and angst, which is constantly seeking to overcome seeminly life-or-death obstacles and stresses, both real and imagined, and yet still vitally human. It's just a little bit harder to swallow when that society is your own.

See here for a great interview with Nanette Burstein on making American Teen.

(foreground) Megan, (left to right) Hannah, Mitch, Luke, and Colin




Why Jason? Why!?!?

With Death Race having recently fizzed at the box office, I've taken a little time to reflect on Jason Statham’s career and all I can think is why? Why Jason? Why? You play the same role in every movie. We get it, you are a badass and can kick people in the face on demand. There is nothing wrong with just doing action movies. I wish some people would stick to just action movies (The Rock), but Mr. Statham you have proved that you can be better. We all know you can. We have seen you in Guy Ritchie movies. Are you only comfortable actually acting when you speak with a British accent? I loved you as Turkish in Snatch; you weaved the story together perfectly and received a moderate amount of critical acclaim. Then Guy Ritchie let go of your hand and you just wandered around like a confused child. You decided you couldn’t act in a movie unless it had a featured at least one car chase and no less than ten on screen deaths.

You may think that I am being a bit harsh but let me remind you of The One, The Transporter, The Italian Job, Transporter 2, Crank, The Bank Job, and now Deathrace. I don’t dislike all of these movies, my problem is they are pretty much the same movie: Man against the odds, some sort of outlandish task has to be completed, and lots of car chases and hand to hand combat. You can do better! Take a chance with something different. You might fail but you might also be able to extend your career as well. Sooner or later people are going to get tired of watching you play the exact same part in every movie (Brendan Fraser). I hope getting into character doesn't challenge you too much, although I can't imagine Transporter 3, Crank 2, and The Brazilian Job being to much of a stretch for you.

Telluride 2008 Recap

With the fall festival season now upon us, this past weekend saw the coming and going of the 35th annual Telluride Film Festival in Telluride, Colorado. For the uninitiated, Telluride is a yearly festival focusing on independent features and featuring national, and even a few worldwide debuts. Thanks to the writer's strike this year's festival was a little lacking on American-made Oscar contenders (Juno, The Savages, and Into the Wild all premiered at last year's festival) but nonetheless showcased a number of very promising domestic and foreign properties ready to be snatched up by specialty studios.


The festival's opening on Friday saw an extended tribute to and interview with director David Fincher (Se7en, The Game, Fight Club, Panic Room and Zodiac). Immediately following the interview Fincher debuted 20 minutes worth of clips for his upcoming holiday release The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, staring Brad Pitt as a man who ages backwards. Reactions to the first extended look at the $150 million dollar feature have been mixed. Industry analysts like Variety's Anne Thompson are insisting it played well, while various bloggers such as Peter over at /film were quite underwhelmed.

The general consensus on this year's standouts include director Marc Abraham's (Children of Men, The Family Man) Flash of Genius, staring Greg Kinear, British breakout Happy-Go-Lucky, and the all-around showstopper, Danny Boyle's Slumdog Millionaire. There was also good buzz around Paul Schrader's Adam Resurrected staring Jeff Goldblum, which is currently without a distributor, but certain to get snagged at the earliest opportunity. Full reviews from around the web below.

+/- Full Reviews

Slumdog Millionaire -- Variety /film first showing
Flash of Genius -- /film
Happy-Go-Lucky -- /film
O'Horton -- first showing
Flame and Citron -- first showing


The Warner's Bros. adaptation of the critically acclaimed Alan Moore graphic novel may be the greatest movie that no one gets to see. Ok, I might be a little over dramatic but due to what is shaping up into a lengthy legal battle; the release date for this superhero epic is now TBA. Warner's Bros. ran into a legal roadblock well into post-production and is now fighting tooth and nail with Fox's legal department over the rights to the film. Fox is seeking an injunction on the films release citing claims of ownership. Apparently Watchmen producer Lawrence Gordon shopped the film around to other studios with the consent of Fox. Now that filming is complete, a trailer has been released, and millions of fans are very excited Fox seems to want its script back. With legal proceedings not set until next June (if Fox gets their way) or next April (if Warner's gets their way) I am afraid I will be taking my kids to this movie (who won't be born for quite some time). We can all hope that this matter gets resolved quickly and quietly, but I am afraid the March 6, 2009 release date may have just turned into more of a pipe dream. Hopefully this trailer will help hold you over.

+/- Watchmen Trailer



CLARIFICATION: The dude at the end of the trailer is not me and has nothing to do with this blog.

With the unofficial end of summer upon us, five films vie for remnants of your summer movie bucks. Disaster Movie, Babylon A.D., Hamlet 2, Traitor, and College all open this weekend. It would appear that there is a film for everyone in that smorgasbord of fresh titles, and each will most likely rake in respective box office numbers. This weekend closes a surprisingly profitable summer for Hollywood, expected to make around 4 billion dollars by the close of the summer season. Down slightly from the record setting summer last year, which grossed over 4.16 billion dollars. This summer has proved that Hollywood is not quite yet completely out of new ideas. We here at Surreelfilm will be publishing our summer recap at the end of this week in case you missed anything. Until then take your pick of movie genres this week, or indulge your inner sports fan and sit on your coach and watch the opening weekend of college football, like me.

UPDATE: Ben Stiller's Tropic Thunder comfortably edged out Vin Diesel's Babylon A.D. for the top spot this past weekend, bringing in $14.3 million and $12 million respectively. Disaster Movie opened at $6.9 million.

The Wrestler, staring Mickey Rourke, is building strong buzz going into it's pending debut at the Venice Film Festival on September 5th, and again two days later at the Toronto International Film Festival. Directed by Darren Aronofsky of Requiem for a Dream and Pi, The Wrestler follows the story of Randy "the ram" Robinson (Rourke), an ex-professional wrestler, forced into retirement by severe heart problems. Living with an aging stripper (Marisa Tomei) and her son, Robinson is drawn back into the sport by the prospect of a rematch with old nemesis the Ayatollah (Ernest Miller).

With whispers of oscar-worthy status in the air, The Wrestler is almost certain to get snatched up by a studio specialty division and dropped into a theater near you as soon as possible. Nicolas Cage was originally attached to play the title role, but left the project for undisclosed reasons. Director Darren Aronofsky was recently confirmed for MGM's 2010 reboot of the Robocop franchise.

Rourke and his on-set trainer, real-life wrestler Afa Anoa'i


Bolstered by the upcoming Criterion release of Wes Anderson’s Bottle Rocket, I finally took the time to check out the film, and discovered a classic effort that Martin Scorsese has labeled as one of the top-ten films of the 1990s.

The Skinny: As Anderson’s first full length feature, 1996’s Bottle Rocket is an immensely enjoyable and entertaining farce of a heist movie that demonstrates many of the trademarks and quirks that have come to define the Anderson’s films. It features brothers Luke, Owen, and yes even the phantom Andrew Wilson, alongside actors Robert Musgrave and James Caan. The film opens as Owen Wilson’s character Dignan helps Luke Wilson’s Anthony to “break out” of a voluntary-stay mental care facility. After meeting up with mutual friend Bob, played by Musgrave, the threesome proceed to set out on a series of misadventures in their efforts to become big-time criminals. The film deals with a number of themes ranging from brotherhood and love, to depression, and carries on with the same innocent sense of humor that shines throughout all of Wes Anderson’s writing. Bottle Rocket is easily the most accessible of any of Anderson’s films, and can therefore serve as both a perfect introduction for Anderson neophytes, or as a refreshing change of pace for dedicated fans.
+/- Full Review

Friends Anthony and Dignan, played by brothers Luke and Owen Wilson respectively, serve as the central characters of the film, while third friend Bob exists on the periphery of their three-man “team”. Anthony is a twenty-something who checked himself into a mental facility upon the realization that he was completely miserable with the state of his life and utterly hopeless. His character is recovering gradually from his bout with depression, but is actually a closet idealist, as illustrated by his love-at-first-sight affection for Inez, the Paraguayan maid of a hotel where the three stay. Dignan is a fundamentally insecure guy who is prone to jealousy and covers up for it by being extremely energetic and over-the-top. He desperately wants to be the mastermind of the group, but his ridiculous schemes hold nothing but empty promises that usually end up fucking things up for one or more of the participants. Bob has been beat up and degraded by his older brother, played by Andrew Wilson, for his entire life and desperately wants to be a member of the group, but his paranoia leads him to suspect the other two of wanting to cut him out of the deal at any given opportunity. His is drafted as the group’s getaway driver, as he is the only one that owns a car.

The themes of Bottle Rocket are largely consistent with the hallmarks of Wes Anderson’s works, but with a few key differences. While the main characters are all damaged and fragile in their own way, the film lacks the sense of tragedy displayed in many of Anderson’s other films. However, sympathy for the characters is by no means diminished, as the woes that befall them are ultimately much more grounded than the extreme absurdity of later efforts like The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou. Of course, that’s not to say that the plot doesn’t have it’s moments of delightful absurdity. As to the film’s sense of humor, Anderson’s use of understatement is masterfully intact. In one the opening sequences Luke Wilson explains to a sorority-type girl the powerful motivations and realizations that lead him to seek professional help, only for her to respond, “you’re really complicated aren’t you?” He replies, “I try not to be.” One other thematic constant of Anderson’s films that makes an appearance is the respected middle-aged male who turns out to be a complete fraud. Here the character is James Caan’s Mr Henry, who is the owner of the lawn and landscaping service that serves as the cover for the criminal organization from which Dignan draws all of his inspiration. Interestingly, one Anderson staple missing from this story is the prevalence of smoking, and an escapist embrace of drug use.

In terms of the cinematography and production style employed in Bottle Rocket, it’s much the same story in that many of the established Anderson elements are present, but not all. Anderson’s pension for unique staging was prevalent from the first scene, and he utilizes close-ups and quick cuts throughout the film in order to create a playful and dynamic rhythm to all of the sequences. This sense of rhythm and style is further buoyed by Anderson’s oddball music selection, which is just a sharp here as ever. Missing is the vivid pastel color palette of his later work, but this can be most easily explained by a comparatively small budget. However, fear not, as the use of Futura Bold font for all credits is present and accounted for. (sigh of relief)

Bottle Rocket is a refreshing look back to the Wes Anderson of yesteryear, and a satisfyingly entertaining romp to boot. Many critics of Anderson have felt that his films have become progressively more bizarre since Rushmore, and that his characters have become less and less relatable. While this criticism is probably fair, I have continued to be a fan of his work through last year’s Darjeeling Limited, and will continue to be until some point in the future when he actually goes fucking crazy. And even then I’ll probably still give him a chance. Bottle Rocket is not only Anderson at his most unfiltered, but perhaps his most human as well, and is therefore an easy recommendation to any fan of quality cinema.

So.... what do a forgettable Indiana Jones sequel and a 1994 MacGyver TV movie have in common? The same horrible ending! Thanks a lot George Lucas.


To say that the character Ant-Man is obscure in the minds of the general public is an understatement. In a recent interview with Wizard Universe director Edgar Wright reaffirmed his commitment to bringing his "A-game" for one of marvel's "D-list" heroes.

Currently working on the film's second draft, the Hot Fuzz and Shaun of the Dead director admits, "The whole raison d'etre of the piece for me and my thing has always been to take something that would seem to be uncool and make it really cool and that's certainly the case with British cops in Hot Fuzz. To take the most seemingly kind of underwhelming concept and make something really cool out of it—I always liked that premise." His pedigree speaks for itself, but I'd say he's got his work cut out for him.

There have been three Ant-men in the history of Marvel's cannon and Wright's script purports to include all three of them via a series of flashes between the 60s and 80s. Ant-man is tentatively set for a 2011 release.

Sony pictures has announced that a big screen adaptation of Wildstorm comics' The Boys is in the works. The super-violent series follows the exploits of a squad of superhero CIA agents who are charged with the duty of keeping watch on other superheroes, and using deadly force whenever necessary.

As interesting as this property sounds, I'm very nervous as to whether or not the pro-PG13 Dark Knight copycat machine will allow it to be made in the horrifically R-rated fashion that the materials calls for. And second, writers Matt Manfredi and Phil Hay of Aeon Flux and The Tuxedo are handling the adaptation, which doesn't bode well for my confidence either. No director has been attached the project.



All misgivings aside, this will be an interesting one to follow as it progresses. Here's hoping for a pleasant surprise.